Ramey; AKM-GSI; FameFlynet; Splash News Online; Beverly News

We admit we’ve worn sweats to the grocery store before — seriously, who hasn’t? — but seeing stars get dressed to grab the basics always makes us want to set the bar a bit higher.

Take Jessica Alba (left), who manages to make her grocery run comfy-chic in a maxi, cardigan and hat. Or Halle Berry (second from left), whose white top, jean shorts and flip-flops say “casual cool.” Zoë Saldana (center), Kate Bosworth (second from right) and January Jones (right) also use the simple errand run as an opportunity to get glam, without looking like they tried too hard.

So which star’s grocery store style is best? Vote in our poll below — your responses could appear in an upcoming issue of PEOPLE!

Take Our Poll